I started taking French in 5th grade in an early-morning enrichment program offered through my elementary school. If you can believe it, the program didn’t even offer Spanish; it was French or nothing. That a school program that could only afford to offer one language would choose French instead of Spanish is sort of amazing to me- the world hasn’t changed THAT much in the past 20 years, has it? If one had been paying attention, couldn’t one have foreseen that Spanish, (a language that is spoken at home by over 28 million people in the US according to the 2000 census) would be the more useful choice? (To provide some point of comparison, the 2000 census estimates that slightly fewer than 2 million people in the US speak French at home.)
My mother, I think, dreamed of having daughters who grew up studying French the way young ladies in Jane Austen novels grow up studying French (and learning to play the pianoforte, and doing needlework, and taking a turn about the room.) It seemed romantic to her. She imagined that one day my sister and I would take trips to Europe and drive around in cheaply-purchased used Volkswagens and meet cute European boys, just like she had done with her best friend upon her graduation from college. Though I took a mandatory 6-week minicourse in Spanish in middle school, I don’t think I ever really had a choice about what language I would take going forward- I continued with French through high school, and then took some courses in college and studied abroad in Paris as a junior.
Turns out, I kind of have a knack for languages. I speak much better French than I rightfully should for how little effort I put into my French studies growing up. When I travel to a francophone country, I slip fairly effortlessly into speaking in French, and feel comfortable communicating with locals. I can get myself out of scrapes. (Remind me to tell you the funny story about the time I went off on a shady French guy who was trying hard to persuade me and my friend (both a little drunk) to go home to his apartment to look at his posters. I didn’t know I knew how to say “holy crap you are such a cliché and even if we did trust you we would not go home with a guy who can’t come up with a better line than that” in French until it was out of my mouth and we were walking away from him.)
Now I’m not knocking French- I LOVED studying in Paris and like visiting France and generally enjoy any culture that can strike over the arduousness of a 35 hour work week and get that excited about cheese- but MAN do I wish I’d taken Spanish. If I had that kind of familiarity in Spanish? Oh my god it would be AWESOME.
I have long lamented my lack of Spanish skillz, and my wish for Spanish is in full force again after having spent last week on a team visiting a dual language elementary school. Most of the students speak Spanish at home, and at least half the day (and substantially more than that in the lower grades) is taught in Spanish. The theory behind the program is that teaching literacy skills in the native language first will actually improve a child’s chances of learning to read effectively in English. Setting aside for the moment debates about bilingual education (don’t particularly want to dip my toes into that particular cesspool of vitriolic debate in this little blog post) this school was just awesome. Being there was awesome. I have a reasonable familiarity with Spanish having taught for a few years in a place where Spanish and not English was the dominant language, and I was pleased as punch to discover that I actually understood most of what was happening, even in those classes that were being taught in Spanish. (It was also nice to discover that as much as I loved being around the kids- which I really really did- I didn’t find myself wishing to be classroom teacher again. This is progress, since for the first two years of law school I wished I were back in the classroom on a near-daily basis. But I digress.) But when a little second grader came up to me and asked me a question in Spanish? All I could really come up with was “lo ciento, mijo, no hablo español, hablo francés.”
Can I really blame him for looking at me like I was an alien?
How sketchy would it be, exactly, to look for a Spanish language speaking partner on craigslist? Anyone out there want to teach me Spanish, perhaps? Any other suggestions of how I might improve my Spanish without shelling out hundreds of dollars to a language school? Because seriously, to do the kind of work I want to do with my law degree, Spanish can only help. Francés? Not so much.
ME, TOO! I can’t believe there’s someone else out there who started learning languages in 5th grade … and NOT SPANISH! That’s entirely too funny.
One thing I was told when learning FRENCH (sigh) was to speak with children – they have a simple grasp of language and are not likely to use confusing phrases/cliches adults use. So, maybe you should get involved with a Spanish-speaking family … let Mom run errands while you hang out with the kids … and practice your Spanish (and maybe help them with English)?? Just a thought…
I am the same way. Off I went, learning French even though I KNEW I should really be learning Spanish. But the worst part? Is that it turned out, the whole time, that I really should have been learning German! Gah.
Me three! WTF was I thinking NOT taking Spanish? I had the romantic ideas about French too, but that doesn’t matter now.
Maybe on CL you can trade skills: knitting for Spanish-speaking in the barter section?
Oh, yo amo español! Brian wants a Spanish partner too. You should find one together. I don’t think it’s shady at all to look on craigslist, or even just email a bunch of people and ask if they know anyone.
Bilingual education nerd alert! I HEART dual language academies, and I also heart their theories on how children learn better when they are allowed to learn in their native language as well! It’s so true!
I learned no foreign languages growing up. I was excused from that requirement due to my difficulties in learning (which of course we later found out were due to learning disabilities).
However. When I had a french roommate I learned that I knew way more french than I thought. And you’ll find the same with Spanish – especially since you already know French.
Anyway, it’s not weird to do the craigslist thing, but as your … blogfriend who has a very cautious and untrusting mother who worries too much, here’s my suggestion:
Post the ad saying “My husband and I would like to learn…” and then when you meet the person, say your husband’s no longer interested and it’ll just be you.
Teach yourself the basics first. Alphabet, numbers, colors, pieces of clothing, parts of the body, family members, weather, etc. Also, if there’s a spanish radio station, start listening to it – you’ll totally pick up some stuff that way.